THE LATEST, IN FOCUS
← NewsFix home
Dorset

Huge waste dump blamed on Environment Agency delays

Approx. 6 min read
Huge waste dump blamed on Environment Agency delays

Read the original reporting ↗

More than 28,000 tonnes of waste has been left at a quarry where the landowner claims the Environment Agency (EA) failed to act quickly enough over repeated permit breaches.

Building minerals supplier MB Wilkes said it now faced an estimated £3m bill to clear the site near Corfe Mullen in Dorset.

The company said concerns were raised a year after leasing the land to waste operator Hillier Recycling – but the rubbish continued to arrive for six more years before the EA revoked its permits.

Three men pleaded guilty to offences relating to the site in September, and the EA said it would not respond to the allegations from MB Wilkes until after the sentencing hearing later this month.

However, the EA's chief executive said at a recent Environment and Climate Change Committee hearing that permits were too rarely suspended or revoked despite repeated breaches – and that needed to change.

Hillier Recycling went into liquidation in 2024 having abandoned an estimated 28,500 tonnes of rubbish at the site.

Paul Wilkes, director of MB Wilkes, seems lost for words as he walks through the site surveying the mounds of rubbish.

"Don't know what to say really. It's mind blowing," he told the BBC.

"The Environment Agency let it happen."

The company leased the land for 10 years to waste operators Hillier Recycling in 2015.

Hillier obtained two permits from the Environment Agency to handle inert waste – soil and rubble – and mixed commercial and industrial waste at the site.

But within a year the landowner had voiced concerns about how the site was being run and the type of waste being handled.

"We actually said to the Environment Agency can you please stop them coming and tipping and they said 'don't worry we've got it all in hand' – and nothing happened. The lorries still came," said Wilkes.

MB Wilkes became so desperate to stop more waste being brought to the site that employees tried to blockade the entrance with a lorry.

But the company was told to remove the vehicle as it was a breach of the conditions of the lease of the land to Hillier Recycling.

After Hillier Recycling abandoned the site and the 10-year lease expired, the EA served the landowner, WB Wilkes, with a Section 59 notice.

It requires the landowner to remove the waste, even though they did not handle it, within a specified timeframe.

The UK operates the polluter pays principle.

But if a waste operator goes out of business, the costs of the clear-up often falls on the landowner.

Consultants acting on behalf of MB Wilkes said questions must be asked about how the EA acted when concerns were raised and the issue of the licences to handle waste.

"In my opinion, the two permits that were issued here should never have been issued by the Environment Agency in the first place," said managing director of Somerton Environmental, Rebecca Bomers.

"This site was supposed to have, amongst other things, a building so all waste for the commercial waste permit should have been kept, treated, stored inside a building.

"As you can see there are no buildings here.

"Also all the surfaces of the site should have been impermeable."

Neither conditions have ever been met on the site.

According to records gathered by Bomers, the EA made more than 20 visits to the site between 2015 and 2022.

The EA repeatedly asked Hillier Recycling to address concerns identifying numerous breaches to the terms of the permits.

Due to the accumulated scores of the persistent breaches, the site was categorised as a Compliance Band E – the second lowest rating.

Hillier Recycling was allowed to continue to handle waste.

In one email exchange, the EA told the operator to bring more waste to the site when another of its operations went over capacity.

Vikki Slade, Liberal Democrat MP for Mid Dorset North Poole, said details of the site were concerning.

"It is beyond belief that additional waste has been allowed to be dumped on a site that had already been reported for breaches of permits," she said.

"Time and again we see the Environment Agency acting too slowly and not using their powers robustly enough.

"Situations like this – and the one in Kidlington that has received so much publicity – are causing huge environmental damage and undermine the public's faith in the authorities."

In November 2021, following repeated failures, the EA suspended acceptance of all waste at the site.

But just four days later the terms of the suspension were amended and inert waste once again began arriving at the site as breaches of the permits continued.

According to the landowner, other types of waste also continued to be brought to the site.

On the 28 September 2022, the EA stopped all waste coming to the site.

According to landowner MB Wilkes, the EA's failure to ensure compliance led to thousands more tonnes of waste piling up.

From the rubbish strewn across the site it is clear household waste, not permitted at the site, has also been dumped.

The EA said it could not comment on this case due to legal proceedings.

But during a recent Environment and Climate Change Committee hearing, chief executive of the EA Philip Duffy addressed concerns over permits.

"It is I think to my mind, and to the minds of those who look at the Environment Agency, peculiar that the agency issues permits to regulate all sorts of activity but we very rarely revoke them or suspend them, which means that you can, in some cases, breach those permits year after year with no great consequence.

"We want to change that."

Duffy was also quizzed about allowing poorly rated sites like MB Wilkes' Henbury Quarry – rated Band E – being allowed to continue to operate.

"What I think is not acceptable is that we allow an operator to stay in D, E and F where we've got really quite severe concerns about non compliance year after year," he said.

"That has been the situation that we've had previously and that is clearly unacceptable, and our simple message here is if you are in band D, E and F, yes, you'll get the opportunity to improve.

"If you don't improve you'll be suspended. If you still don't improve you'll have your permit revoked."

For now the landowner is appealing against demands from the EA to clear up the mess.

Anna Willetts, a partner at law firm gunnercooke, said it left the landowner "in a very difficult position".

"[Wilkes] had huge quantities of waste deposited on his land, permitted by the Environment Agency, put there by somebody else," she said.

"Asked for help to stop – it was never stopped – and he's now been served a notice to clear it up.

"If he doesn't comply with the notice he'll potentially be in breach of that, which is a criminal offence."

News of this waste dump comes a year after a huge rubbish mountain was reported in Kidlington, Oxfordshire, that later cost £6m to clear.


Source: BBC UK
Read the original story
Author: Jon Cuthill

Discussion

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

YOUR READING LIST

Saved for later

Stored on this browser only. Clearing browser data removes your list.

MAKE IT YOURS

Follow your interests

Choose up to 8 topics. Preferences stay in this browser.